950 and 955 Trinks (lucky) - TV or GS??

[Srig]

I'm strictly a HC raider, we won't do mythic raiding.

I love GS and was committed to it until the "great destruction of mastery" killed the scaling potential of GS then reverted to IV build and have been running that.

HOWEVER... in the past couple of weeks, my weekly chest has been very generous to me and I got a 950 Tome of Unraveling Sanity and a 955 Portable Manacracker. Already have a 920 owl and a 915 Terror.

Wondering if these trinks might increase their relative value if I run GS build and ensure i'm crit-capped (which is key to the build) or if the crit boost from Tome will be wasted. I'll sim it but thoughts are appreciated.

Portable Manacracker
Item Level 955
Binds when picked up
Unique-Equipped
Trinket
+3,444 Intellect
Equip: Your damaging critical strikes have a chance to apply Volatile Magic. At 6 stacks Volatile Magic is converted into Withering Consumption, dealing (56735 * 5) Arcane damage over 12 sec.
Requires Level 110
Sell Price: 34 30 41
Dropped by: Ivanyr
Drop Chance: 2.70%

and

Tome of Unraveling Sanity
Mythic
Item Level 950
Binds when picked up
Unique-Equipped
Trinket
+3,287 [Agility or Intellect]
Use: Deal 454965 Shadow damage over 12 sec. When this effect ends or the target dies, you gain 3200 Critical Strike for 12 sec plus any time remaining on the effect. (1 Min Cooldown)
Requires Level 110
Sell Price: 52 87 95
Dropped by: Kil'jaeden

[Abscond]

How do you guys know to post here but don't know how to sim.
Download simcraft, sim the trinkets. I really doubt they are going to be better than shark/birb for tv.

[Srig]

The same way you know how to respond to a post but not how to read one.

" I'll sim it but thoughts are appreciated. "

derp

[Foolosophy]

The thing is that it all depends on your gear set.. I have a 910 arcana crystal and this thing sims higher than my 915 shark. Which the trinket graph that circulates around here doesn’t show..

[durrtygoodz]

The same way you know how to respond to a post but not how to read one.

" I'll sim it but thoughts are appreciated. "

derp

My thought is, you should sim.